Skip to content
Clear Tools Journal

The Educational Propaganda Highlighted by an Academy Award-Winning Documentary – Is It Actually Effective?

After her young daughter was instructed to learn a verse about Russia's "glorious army" for a school event, a mother from Moscow believed it was over the top.

She has faced difficulties to insulate her child from a rising number of labeled "nationalistic" initiatives in the education system.

This ramping up of military propaganda aimed at the country's students has been vividly depicted for a worldwide audience in an Oscar-winning documentary.

The film, created by a former teacher and videographer from a small town in the Ural mountains, shows how school activities were progressively woven into pro-government narratives following the full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

What troubles the mother deeply is that her daughter genuinely enjoys participating in the government-sponsored initiative.

"My daughter likes her teacher, she gets along with her classmates – she likes being a part of it," she says.

She worries that openly objecting to school activities could socially isolate her daughter. Once, when she decided to keep her child home to avoid a flag-raising ceremony, her daughter was disappointed. "I don't want her to feel like she doesn't belong," the mother states.

The Film's Footage

The documentary details how the filmmaker was gradually swept up in the government propaganda apparatus.

Additional ceremonies and compulsory lessons were introduced, aimed at teaching the government's perspective on history and current events.

History books were revised to incorporate the latest developments, termed as a "special military operation."

These measures have persisted. Just last month, the government announced plans for a official list of toys and games for preschools to promote "patriotism."

The core messages are unambiguous: the invasion is necessary, and patriotism requires unquestionable support. At home, however, some families encounter different views.

Young Students' Experiences

One young boy, Maksim, enthusiastically lists what he has learnt in his "patriotic education" lessons: topics ranging from great Russian poets to friendship and including military technology.

"They told us this is how to prepare for war," he remarks.

His mother, who opposes the war, refrains from publicly discussing her views in front of him, fearing he might repeat it in public.

"An active anti-war position might draw unwanted attention," she explains.

Expert Insight

Navigating the divide between school messages and family beliefs is challenging, says a psychotherapist.

"A child has to live in the school setting – attending school, being part of the class," the expert notes. "However, this isn't parents should align with the propaganda. But there is little benefit in taking a political stance in front of your child."

She advises parents focus on broader principles like the sanctity of human life and dialogue – instead of openly challenging the official line.

Research indicate children in early grades are particularly receptive to messages from authority figures. "When told to a young child that war is good, they will believe it," she adds.

"If parents consistently diverge with institutional messaging, parental guidance usually prevails in the end," states a researcher in behavioural genetics.

Yet, when the state dominates most media and education and different viewpoints are limited, the outcome is less predictable. This is the case in the present Russian context.

Historical studies into past state education suggest that systemic messaging can have long-lasting effects, particularly when reinforced by the broader social environment.

Varied Implementation

The enforcement of government directives varies widely across schools.

Some institutions embrace them zealously, while others dilute or sidestep the requirements. Individual teachers may adapt, minimize, or avoid the prescribed content.

In scenes from the documentary, children are shown handed Russian flags during a school assembly to watch a announcement about a state-run children's movement.

In a separate lesson, a class is warned that the "opposition" will try to recruit from within their own ranks.

Teenage Disengagement

The compulsory talks, called "Important Conversations," are frequently met with boredom by teenagers.

One teenager from St Petersburg, Maia, says they are "very boring."

"No one engages in the conversation. We just are present and pretend to listen, then leave," she explains.

"Forcing citizens to engage in public displays of patriotism is a way of reminding them of the regime's overwhelming power," notes a academic expert in Russian studies. This perception is strengthened by controlled information and orchestrated public events, he adds.

To further leverage this "patriotic education," authorities made easier the process for school-leavers to enlist in the military in 2023, sometimes using financial incentives as enticement.

Maia, who shares her parents' critical view of the war, avoids the topic at school and is unsure what her peers truly think.

"At first I was anxious that I would clash with those who support the war," she remembers. "But nowadays, everyone acts so neutrally that everything seems normal."

About the author

Larry White

Laura is a productivity coach and minimalist enthusiast who helps professionals streamline their digital lives.

Clear Tools Journal

Type to search articles.